When Systems Unravel
Why slowly improving alternatives may undermine incumbents abruptly once participation, costs or legitimacy pass a threshold.
Model & Argument · Initial edition, November 2026
Technologies can improve gradually while institutions remain remarkably stable. Then something changes quickly.
One explanation is a threshold: once an alternative becomes attractive enough to enough people, the old system's own economics can begin working against it.
The mechanism
Consider an incumbent network with substantial fixed costs. A handful of users choosing an alternative changes little. But if departures accumulate, the remaining users may face higher costs, poorer service or declining investment. That makes departure more attractive to the next group.
Positive feedback can turn a slow shift into a sudden loss of viability.
A similar process can affect institutions dependent on legitimacy, talented participants, suppliers or cross-subsidies.
The role of lag
Incumbents can be highly successful even as alternative technologies improve. Their assets, customers, established procedures and ability to influence policy let them preserve the status quo.
That may defer adjustment and accumulate tension. Once adaptation becomes unavoidable, the eventual change can be more disruptive than earlier gradual reform would have been.
This is one possible mechanism behind the Three Legs of Civilisation: energy and technology change first; organisation follows later and sometimes discontinuously.
Not every system spirals
Institutions can adjust tariffs, reallocate assets, introduce new services and reduce fixed costs. Public policy can spread the burden. Some infrastructures become more valuable as adoption grows.
The threshold story must therefore be demonstrated case by case rather than applied to every declining business.
Where to look
Electricity distribution, petroleum logistics, digital platforms and global production networks provide different potential examples. Each needs its own cost structure and evidence. The Electricity Network's Dilemma explores a concrete mechanism.
The larger hypothesis is that several interacting thresholds might produce a 2030s rupture, but a plausible mechanism does not establish its date.