Australia Is Not America

Australia should analyse its choices independently rather than importing America's political crises and strategic assumptions.

Model & Argument · Initial edition, November 2026

Australia's media, institutions and political culture are deeply connected to the United States. But Australia is not America. It has different geography, political institutions, economic structures, social history and exposure to the world's changing balance of power.

That sounds obvious. Yet strategic and political debate often treats American problems and assumptions as though they were naturally Australian.

The danger of inherited thinking

Australia's security relationships developed during a period in which American global predominance could be taken for granted. If that period is ending, old policy assumptions deserve examination.

Alliance relationships still have real value. The question is whether Australia is cultivating enough independent capability and regional understanding to make choices when American preferences, interests or capacity change.

Technology and material independence

Energy is one starting point. Australia has considerable renewable resources but depends heavily on imported liquid fuel. Increasing electrification could reduce exposure to international oil disruption and improve strategic flexibility.

Access to Chinese-made technology is another uncomfortable issue. Industrial equipment, batteries and other products can be useful for Australian self-reliance even when political relationships with their producer are complicated.

The strategic goal is not to exchange complete dependence on one great power for dependence on another.

Political and cultural independence

America's culture wars and institutional crises can dominate Australian discussion without helping explain our own circumstances. Australia's different electoral arrangements, public services and geography create different constraints and possibilities.

A sensible approach begins with Australian interests and the actual regional environment, not emotional allegiance to a foreign political contest.

An open agenda

The argument requires careful treatment of defence, industrial capability, trade, energy, and relationships with neighbours. It doesn't justify simply abandoning alliances or assuming self-reliance can be achieved cheaply.

See The World in Transition, The Multipolar World and Electrification as National Security.

View page as JSON